I need opinions please ^^

[gr4f]

Hey everyone, I hope that everybody is doing well on Thanksgiving eve. I have a quick question concerning the coloring of my comic book. I have 2 different styles that I'm contemplating, and would like your guys' opinions on which one that I should go with. The first is more of a "traditional" look, while the second is more painterly. Thoughts? Crits? Thank you!

first:


second:


one more, kind of like the first:


Thanks guys!

[Di$array]

I like the first, but that's just me . But cannot understand why you cannot have that lovely rendering you have on your second piece on the first. But if your producing a comic i would go with the first.