
Originally Posted by
steampoweredseagoat
Well, my work compared to a professionals would be their's is actually good because they've been doing it forever. It's colored, it's got it's own flare, proper proportions, good use of color, it's, umm, professional and my stuff isn't. I don't understand how comparing my work with others will help me at all. That's the worse thing you could do, to me at least. It's never helped me and I just get discouraged. Though I do understand that sometimes it's good to compare to see what someone did right and what you did wrong. But in order to do that, I feel, you'd have to draw something similar. Like a similar pose or the same still life. I do agree that all critiques have some merit to them but sometimes there is such thing as a bad critique and a good critique. I think it's good to be able to distinguish between the two otherwise your art work will suffer and you'll just drive your self crazy. After all, some things people say are pure opinion and not really actual fact that can help you improve.
A complete work is, well, complete. It has all the components the artist wanted in the picture. It might be in color it might not be. The entire figure might be there it might not be. And yes I would hang a few of my pieces on the wall because I feel a lot of them are complete art works, even my gestures because I think they all flow together very nicely. However, I probably wouldn't put them on a level of professional art work I wouldn't do that with any of my art work because I am still learning and a student. So yeah, I'm still not sure what this person means by "incomplete" and sadly I didn't get the name of the silderoom maintenance guy from my admission counselor (my admission counselor was trying to move some of my stuff from one SCAD portfolio to the next since I had accidentally posted my stuff in the wrong area).
Anyway, I'll try and contact my counselor and see if he knows the name of the guy and where I can contact him. I want a more detailed review. As for my actual portfolio, everything in my portfolio has been from observation since I know that's what art schools like. I had a few people in this thread review it, you were one of them, and two of my professors but other than that not that many people. I've never been to a portfolio day, to be honest I didn't know they existed till a couple of months ago. I missed most of the ones by me by the time I knew they existed. If you want to give my portfolio another look, just click the link in my signature, and tell me what you feel is incomplete that would be great otherwise I will forever be confused. *le sigh*
Bookmarks