Rockhart V. Liquid Penguin ---judged

**Rockhart** · February 27th, 2008, 03:27 PM

What's this?! another duel by Rockhart!!!! (cue groans) hey my thinking is the more duels I enter the better chance I might actually win one ....

but who knows? ok now let's get down to business...
topic 4:
player 1 (Rockhart):produces a dagger
A- your blades glint off oneanother as a fast and horrible duel of speed blurs the battlefield
B- you flip over your oponent jamming a dagger through their ruined defence.

player 2 (Liquid Penguin) :you produce a pet
A - your pet shreds your oponent limb from limb as you swig from your flask of mead.
B - your pet desolves you oponent into a puddle with a dagger sticking up.

Start: Wednesday 8:30 GMT
Deadline: Friday 8:30 GMT

**Liquid Penguin** · February 27th, 2008, 03:59 PM

Mmm, and remember, winning rocks, but this is mostly about improving your skills! (crowd glares menacingly) I mean...eh heh...uh, glory to the victor!

**Rockhart** · February 27th, 2008, 04:53 PM

Well, as promised, a WIP in less that 2 hours

I know he's not really "flipping" over the guy but he still got behind him.... result's going to be the same anyways

**Rockhart** · February 27th, 2008, 05:57 PM

and I am DONE!!!! This one was kind of fun! I played around with some coloredpencils and the end result is kind of cool.... or atleast I think so... :Bashful:

Ok Liquid Penguin your time to shine....

**Liquid Penguin** · February 27th, 2008, 06:19 PM

Alrighty, just kinda got started, so it's pretty messy, but I'm hopin' it'll turn out well.

**Liquid Penguin** · February 27th, 2008, 06:21 PM

Nice, already finished, eh Rockhart? Well, you've still got about eh...45 hours left, maybe you could add a background in? Get rid of some of that negative space? And nice job properly representing the armor, it's comin' along well! Oh, and nice choice on the katar, I hardly ever see anyone choose exotic weapons like those!

**Rockhart** · February 27th, 2008, 07:33 PM

very nice WIP! as you can see I'm not on friendly terms with dogs..... yeah I suppose i could add a background since i have time, but they're not really my strongpoint... I guess I'll try. oh and about the katar... I originally had your guy punching at me and I was thinking to myself "oops! Now how am I going to incorperate a blade without having to redo his whole arm...." and then BAM! it just hit me

...

**Liquid Penguin** · February 27th, 2008, 11:37 PM

Well, my noob gf wants me to go play smash, soz I gotta take a break. Here's the wip so far! I'm tellin' ya Rock, it's a good pic but ya gotta put an environment in there! Gotta do the things ya don't like to get better at them. I'm in the same fix...dunno what to do with my bg either. Hrm...

**Liquid Penguin** · February 29th, 2008, 11:58 AM

I must've tried like, 8 different ways of coloring this pic...I have no idea why, but it will not be colored. I tried reds, purples, blues, oranges, mixes...it's cursed! I really need crits on this, any ideas would be grand. Anyways, I'm outta time, so this is my final. Good luck!

**Rockhart** · February 29th, 2008, 06:58 PM

i like it (even if there are slicht color problems) well i definatly need to add a background..... ok nest duel i PROMISE to use a background

good job Liquid Penguin and best of luck...

**Sentinel.** · March 1st, 2008, 09:25 AM

My best recommendation for coloring a grey scale pic is really taking advantage of photoshop's multiply, overlay, and color adjust capabilities. I rarely if ever start out with the colors I truly want, but by experimenting with my layers I can get some really surprising results. It'll also add a lot of depth and color variety.

I know it's not a specific crit, but I hope it helps at least a little.

**Liquid Penguin** · March 2nd, 2008, 11:54 AM

Cool cool, thanks for the tip! I've only recently started using the grayscale-color method, but it's been really fun. Although, I feel I'm relying too heavily on the color balance tool, along with curves, so I've been trying to trim down on those so as not to develop a cruch. That being said, I tried a ton of different color balances with multiple base overlays, and I just cannot come up with anything appealing for that pic. It's quite frustrating.

**chaosrocks** · March 2nd, 2008, 11:24 PM

rockhart vs Liquid penguin
Alti crx and slash

http://www.conceptart.org/forums/sho...d.php?t=119527

3 Liquid Penguin
although this is better than most of the Rockhart battles thus far
Liquid Penguin - much better image and interesting compositoin, also the character costume idea with the arm strap and awsome pet. nicely done.

**Rockhart** · March 3rd, 2008, 09:23 AM

Originally Posted by chaosrocks

although this is better than most of the Rockhart battles thus far

um... just because i added color (which btw looks nothing like the original)? ok well I guess im 0 for 5 so far....

anyways good duel Liquid Penguin. rematch once I get a tablet ? promise it'll have a background

**cupidsart** · March 3rd, 2008, 09:38 AM

You don't know that you lost your battle against me yet. That one is still a hopefull right?

Originally Posted by Rockhart

um... just because i added color (which btw looks nothing like the original)? ok well I guess im 0 for 5 so far....

anyways good duel Liquid Penguin. rematch once I get a tablet ? promise it'll have a background